FBI Sting Brings in Foutz, Two Others

From the Massillon, Ohio, Evening Independent, Sept. 15, 1955

Herbert Foutz Arrested, Not Convicted in Car Theft Ring

Piecing life stories together through genealogy can seem like standing on the outside, staring through one grimy, cobwebbed window, trying to describe, in detail, rooms throughout the whole house.

Until the lights come on, the other windows are unboarded, the door opens and a welcome mat beckons you inside, you’re left with fragments, glimpses.

And so you come back again, and again, to the house, checking to see if something’s changed. If you’ve gained new access.

In the case of my great-great grandfather Jonathan Foutz‘s family, I’ve been creeping in corners and poking at clues for going on 15 years. We’ve gotten to know my great-grandfather Vance Foutz‘s branch of the tree well, and solved some other mysteries along the way. But there are some stories, no matter how you nudge and dig, that stubbornly refuse to yield the whole picture.

In these cases, even the passage of (more) time doesn’t loosen the grip of the unknown:

• the major players are deceased, or unaware of the answers, or far, far away in the world
• published newspaper stories cease following up on the case
• scanned records sit behind a paywall
• other records may be tangled up in impossibly bad transcriptions, waiting for a perfectly worded search
• still other sources have yet to be released, such as the 1960 census as the clock ticks, too slowly, through the 72-year waiting period

For the family and descendants of Vance’s closest brother, Charles Ross Foutz, all of these factors persist, in the midst of tantalizing clues: my grandfather Don Foutz’s memories recording “red-headed cousins from Canton visiting;” and descendants commenting on this blog, and contacting me through email to share what they know, and attempt to find out still more.

Today’s story is incomplete, but another fascinating one, concerning Charles’s son Herbert Ross Foutz.

September 15, 1955: headlines in nearly two dozen newspapers across Ohio trumpet “Auto Theft Ring Broken in Canton.” As followed up the next day by the Massillon, Ohio Evening Independent:

FBI agents arrested three men here Thursday night during a probe of an interstate car theft gang which specializes in big automobiles.

The investigation was focused mainly on Canton and Erie, Pa.

Arrested were Louis J. Christian, 35, who quit recently as credit manager of a jewelry store here; Herbert R. Foutz, 43, an auto dealer; and Paul Keatley, 28, a jobless truck driver.

They were charged with conspiracy to transport a stolen 1954 Cadillac coupe from Canton to Erie.

In Pittsburgh, an assistant U.S. Attorney, W.W. Stanton, told a reporter that the FBI had to act quickly “because we had information that one of the suspects, Christian, was about to leave the country.”

The three were taken to Cleveland where U.S. Commissioner H. A. Horn set the following bonds: Christian, $10,000; Keatley, $5,000; and Foutz, $10,000. Foutz posted his bail but Christian and Keatley still were held last night in the Cuyahoga county jail at Cleveland.

Prosecution of the charges probably will take place in Pennsylvania.

Friday, Sept. 16, 1955, page 10

Marriage, Seven Kids in Canton

Herbert was third of five children born to Charles Foutz and Rosie Belle White in New Philadelphia before Charles’s early death, at 32, of pneumonia in 1918.

When Rosie remarried a year later, to Thomas Clifford Colvin, the family gained two step-brothers, Clarence and Carl, and moved to Canton by 1922, where two half-sisters, Norma Jessie, and Betty Jane (known as Rose), were born.

By the 1930 census, only the youngest Foutz brother and sister, James and Margaret, live at home with their two young sisters and parents. By the mid-1930s through the 1940s, Canton city directories pick up Charles Foutz’s sons, John, Herbert and James, living with and working with each other: in 1936 at the same residence at 708 3rd St., NE, and for a time at Berger Manufacturing, where Herbert was a cabinet inspector.

By 1945, James is a driver for Mack Beverage Company, and Herbert is a salesman for Superior Dairy. And by the 1950s, after the deaths of their mother, Rosie, in 1948, and oldest brother, John Charles Foutz, in 1950, Herbert is a car salesman.

Early hits in the newspaper record show Herbert as potentially rounded up in 1932 with a Clifford Colvin (could it be his stepfather) for violating Prohibition. But another article in 1950 seems closer to his role in the auto industry in the 1950s and prior to his death — he is reportedly fired by the Ford Motor Company after a four-day union strike in Canton. In the census that year he is listed as a combustion analyst for an auto manufacturing company but “unable to work.”

In 1952, Herbert Foutz appears as a salesman for Shaffer Motors in Massillon in more than a dozen ads running in the Massillon Independent.

Strangely, the newspaper record doesn’t yield up any other ads featuring Herbert Foutz before or after. And then there’s the news of the day for Sept. 15 and 16, when the FBI brings him in.

The Akron Beacon Journal goes into more detail:

FIND AKRON LINK IN CAR THEFTS

FBI agents arrested three men in Canton Thursday as they continued their investigation of an interstate car theft gang specializing in big automobiles.

Taken into custody were Louis J. Christan, 35, who just quit his job as credit manager of a jewelry firm in canton; Herbert R. Foutz, 43, an auto dealer, and Paul Keatley, 28, a jobless truck driver. All three are from Canton.

The trio has been charged with conspiracy to transport a stolen 1954 Cadillac coupe from Canton to Erie, Pa.

Stark County sheriff’s deputies also have been working on the case which reportedly involved an unnamed used car lot in Akron. Deputies said the gang’s operations may involve the disappeaance of 34 blank auto title forms from the Stark County courthouse last Summer.

One of the blank forms, filled out to match a car, turned up in Akron. The man who brought the car in to sell fled when he became frightened. He forgot the title and car.

H. O. Hawkins, FBI chief in Cleveland, said the Cadillac coupe was stolen in Canton Feb. 16 and found two days later on a used car lot in Erie.

…

Foutz posted his bond but Christian and Keatley were still held in Cuyahoga County Jail.

In Cleveland Loren E. Van Brocklin, assistant U.S. attorney, indicated the three men probably would be prosecuted in Pennsylvania where the warrants for their arrest were issued. Foutz, father of six, already has agreed to face charged in that state.

Sept. 16, 1955; page 23

Ringleaders sentenced, Foutz goes free?

From then on, there is seemingly no mention of Herbert Foutz in the newspaper record — no ads, no further updates on the FBI case — until his death in January 1963 at age 51. The obituary in the Mansfield, Ohio News Herald reports “ill health had forced him to retire from his job of auto salesman,” but when? I haven’t found city directory records of his occupation after the 1955 arrest, and there is no 1960 census released yet to check.

But about a month after the FBI brought Christian, Foutz and Keatley in, the story picks up in The Pittsburgh Press, where on Oct. 7 two new conspirators are indicted, and no mention is made of Foutz:

The Federal Bureau of Investigation said it is investigating the gang on the possibility it may have stolen 450 autos throughout Pennsylvania, Ohio and New York.

Working with efficiency, the thieves took nothing but the finest model cars, changed the motor numbers and allegedly used an Erie auto dealer as the “fence.”

Those Indicted

Indictments were returned today against:

James Timpe, 30, an Erie auto dealer.

Louis J. Christian, 35, former credit manager of a Canton, Ohio, jewelry company and alleged ring leader of the gang.

Earl S. Carrington, 29, of Canton, described as a fugitive from the charges leveled today.

Henry P. Keatley, 28, of Canton.

The grand jury said Christian apparently hired both Carrington and Keatley to steal the autos in the Cleveland area between last November and February.

Still Investigating

The four men are specifically charged in the theft of five cars, but the case is still under investigation and it appeared other arrests might be forthcoming.

Officers described the gang as specialists who preferred to steal the latest Cadillacs and Oldsmobile 98s, with emphasis on the “hard top” models.

Christian offered his ring members from $100 to $500 for stealing the cars, investigators said.

Changed Numbers

These were taken to an undisclosed Ohio garage where motor numbers were changed and new title certificates were drawn up, according to testimony.

The probers said the autos then were taken to Timpe, who sold them in the Erie area for ab out $3500 for the Cadillacs and around $2500 for the Oldsmobiles.

Conducting the grand jury probe into the auto ring was Assistant U.S. Attorney W. Wendell Stanton.

Mr. Stanton said Christian was arrested in Cleveland last week, on a complaint growing out of his activities and now is lodged in County Jail there.

Friday, Oct. 7, 1955, page 1

The twists and turns are recorded by Pittsburgh and other area newspapers throughout the Fall and following Winter, with highlights including:

• Timpe pleading guilty, and choosing to stay in jail rather than have his father-in-law, Wilbert W. Boyd, bail him out
• Keatley was found to already be serving time in the Ohio State Pentitentiary “on similar charges”
• Christian was first to be sentenced, on Dec. 1, for one year in prison. By then the charge involved transporting 5 stolen cars to Erie, Pa. (Quite a few less than 450)
• Timpe was next to be sentenced, on Dec. 16, to 19 months, again with the report that the ring handled five stolen cars before the FBI shut them down
• Finally, the law caught up with the fugitive Carrington, who was sentenced on Jan. 27, 1956 to three months in County Jail for his part in transporting two of the stolen cars, with the term in addition to two and half months already served.
• Keatley’s sentencing was left for later, after he finished his term in the Ohio pen, but I found no hits in my search.

So, it seems, the caper is concluded, with no further mention of Herbert Foutz. Did he end up sharing evidence with the Feds? Was he mistakenly taken in? Did he ever return to selling cars, or was his “ill health” more a case of ill association with the likes of Christian and Timpe and Carrington and Keatley?

He was buried in Willoughby Village Cemetery, far from his twice-remarried wife, Eleanor, who is buried with third husband Howard Dennis at North Lawn Cemetery in Canton. (Interestingly, her second husband, Ralph Buxton‘s headstone, at still another cemetery, Forest Hill, in Canton, bears her name and birth year, but no death year.) There are no other Foutzes reported as being buried in Willoughby Village Cemetery.

Zula Ley: Little-Known Fact #4

A 1918 portrait shows my great-grandmother, Mary Zula Lucrece (Fisher) Ley, and her newborn son, my grandfather Robert Earl Ley Jr.

Tragic Death Tied to Flu Epidemic

When I started this blog, it was to share what’s most interesting to me about genealogy — the way the lives and personalities of our ancestors come to life in the stories we uncover.

At times those stories are tragic. Perhaps none more so than the story of my great-grandmother, Zula (Fisher) Ley.

Posts in the last weeks have shared snippets of her young life — acclaim for her acting in a senior play, notching a finalist finish in a national beauty contest, sneaking off to Wellsburg, W. Va. to marry Great-Grandpa Earl Ley.

These and other portraits show Zula as vital, intelligent, beautiful.

But her life is defined for her descendants by its tragic end, subject of the second post ever in this blog. It was front-page news in neighboring Dover: how the young wife, 24, of a prominent dentist passed away of influenza and pneumonia late on a Sunday night at home in New Philadelphia, Ohio.

An account in the hometown Daily Times, however, also ties Zula’s death to a sudden epidemic that winter.

The Feb. 2, 1920 edition, front page, broadcasts in bold headlines: FLU EPIDEMIC CLAIMS THREE; RED CROSS TAKES UP BATTLE. Whole Families are Reported Ill. Relief is Sought. Three Persons Die Over Weekend.

While influenza is fast enveloping New Philadelphia in a grip that claimed three fatalities Sunday and Monday the Red Cross is preparing to combat the epidemic with nurses.

Mayor E. N. Fair Monday as chairman of the influenza committee of the Red Cross was seeking a nurse for a family where help could not be obtained to take care of the ill.

Whole families are ill with the epidemic, and many patients were reported on the verge of death, Monday.

Young Wife Dies

Mrs. Mary Zula Ley, 24, wife of Dr. Robert E. Ley, Dover dentist, succumbed to influenza-pneumonia at 11:30 p.m. Sunday following ten days’ illness.

The death of Mrs Ley which occurred at the residence on West High street, caused widespread sorrow.

The husband and one son, Robert Earl, aged 16 months, survive.

…

Years later, with more information known about our family history, it is believed the hereditary presence of Factor V Leiden, which causes abnormal clotting of the blood, particularly in veins, may have contributed to Zula’s death.

Reported in neither paper was the stillborn death of her infant daughter, also named Mary on a separate death certificate.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

 

 

In Memoriam: Nellie Irene (Johnson) Fitzgerald

A pic of the oldest Johnson kids — Leonard, Nellie and Virginia — about 1916.

 

Prayers and hugs for the family of Great Aunt Nellie (Johnson) Fitzgerald, who passed away on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2015.

Her house was always a site for extended family gatherings, full of stories and hugs and ample quantities of comfort food. She was the last surviving sibling in a family that numbered ten: seven brothers, three sisters. They knew hard times, hopping from house to house in the interval between wars. They knew personal tragedy in the loss of wives, brothers, daughters. They served their country and communities. They knit tightly with family and helped each other through.

I know Nellie was particularly proud of making it to 99. I know we all wish she had made it a lot longer than that. And we’re proudest of knowing her.

Below is a slide show of collected images from a life well-lived. And a copy of her obituary. Rest in peace, Aunt Nellie.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

NELLIE IRENE FITZGERALD

Nellie Irene Fitzgerald, age 99, of Uhrichsville, O., passed away on Thursday, November 19, 2015, at Hennis Care Centre, following a lengthy illness.

Born September 4, 1916, at New Philadelphia, Nellie was the daughter of the late Charles and Viola (Palmer) Johnson.

Nellie was a homemaker and a member of the Uhrichsville First Presbyterian Church.  She was a 4-H advisor for 20 years, a Girl Scout Leader, volunteer at the Food Bank, Deacon of the First Presbyterian Church and a member of Homemaker of Union Township.

In addition to her parents, Nellie was preceded in death by her husband DeLoyce P. Fitzgerald, who passed away on June 28, 1985; a daughter Rosann Fitzgerald Kohler; two sisters and 7 brothers.

Nellie is survived by her son Jerry (Rose) Fitzgerald of Uhrichsville and daughter Sara Fitzgerald of Ocala, Florida; 4 grandchildren Pauline Kohler, Parrish (Sharon) Kohler, Katy Fitzgerald and Megan (Jason) McElory; 5 great grandchildren Amanda (Dustin) Martyn, Zachary Kohler, Josh Kohler, Emmitt McElory and Isaac McElroy; 2 great great grandchildren Harley Kohler and Bear Martyn.

Funeral services for Nellie will be held at 1 p.m., on Monday, November 23, 2015 at Uhrich-Hostettler English Funeral Home, Inc. in Uhrichsville with the Rev. Mark Unrue officiating. Burial will follow at Evergreen Burial Park in New Philadelphia.

Calling hours will be from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m., (two hours prior to services) on Monday, November 23, 2015 at the funeral home.

Memorial contributions may be made to the Uhrichsville First Presbyterian Church, 633 N. Main St., Uhrichsville, O., 44683.

A Visit with Great Aunt Nellie | Repost

Colt and his great aunt Nellie (Johnson) Fitzgerald at her home in March 2011.

Hugs & Hospitality in the Home of Nellie (Johnson) Fitzgerald

Great Aunt Nellie (Johnson) Fitzgerald passed away Nov. 19 at age 99. This post, from March 2011, recounts a visit.

—

—

—

I was once a quite enterprising reporter, so I should have known better.

Presented with the chance to spend an afternoon chatting with my Great Aunt Nellie, 94 years young as of last September, I fumbled around with my laptop, spent a good half hour busying my hands consuming trail bologna and deviled eggs and macaroni salad and the like, and utterly failed to pop open a notebook and record our winding conversation with anything more reliable than my own noggin.

Which will have to suffice.

We spent the day chatting in her home, site in the summertime of many a family gathering, afternoons filled with sunshine and pickup softball games and plenty of food and lemonade. There was snow on the ground this time, and a chill in the air. But the atmosphere inside was cozy.

Nellie still lives at home, with some assistance throughout the day, and frequent visits from her son, who lives just up the road a piece. She was also kept company, during our visit, by a former daughter-in-law (I think?) and a great-grandson. So the house was filled with conversation, and I found Nellie to be as delightfully frank, and sweet, and feisty, and fun as I remembered.

My great-grandfather Charles Johnson’s first wife, Leona Miller, died shortly after they were married.

The Tragic Tale of Leona Miller Johnson

Nellie has some trouble getting around these days. She greeted us from her easy chair, and moved about the house with the aid of her “horse” — her walker.

We began our visit by flipping through old photos — everything I had stored up in my Family History Master folder on my computer. She confirmed some of the old relatives I was wondering about, including some beauties of my grandma Erma (Johnson) Foutz as a young teenager (see below), and chuckled at ones of herself shortly after her wedding to DeLoyce Fitzgerald and especially at one of her as a baby, posed with older sibs Leonard and Virginia.

“Oh,” she said (of the photo at the bottom of this post), “I forgot to wear my socks that day!”

Nellie’s house is decorated with scores of old photos and mementos. She was kind enough to have copies made for me of a portrait of my grandmother as a baby, and of my great-great grandparents Palmer (which I featured in yesterday’s post).

In her current bedroom hangs a very unique portrait — that of my great-grandfather (her father) Charles Johnson’s first wife.

Leona Miller and Charles married shortly after Valentine’s Day, 1907. She was 23; he was 20.

According to family lore, and retold by Nellie during our visit, Charles, a coal miner, came home one day, perhaps as early as the week they were married, and found Leona on her hands and knees, scarlet-faced, scrubbing the floor.

As he knelt down to tend to her, Leona collapsed. She died shortly after.

Charles returned to the home of his parents (as noted in the 1910 census), and wouldn’t remarry until 1911, when he wed a girl from nearby Dennison, my great-grandmother, Viola Palmer.

“When you think about it,” I knelt down to murmur in Nellie ear, “it’s a sad story, but without Leona dying, none of us would be here.”

“Oh,” Nellie said, the whisper of a grin on her face, “I don’t know.”

There’s not a lot we know about Leona beyond her fate and the image preserved above. According to the New Philadelphia cemeteries department, she is buried in the same plot as my great-great grandparents Clement and Anna Johnson, but I found no marker to indicate such during my stop at East Avenue/Evergreen the next day.

This picture of my grandma as a very young teenager was taken in 1933, when she was not yet 13. Scribbled on the back: “Camp Birch Creek, F-60, Dillon, Montana. C. 15-1 C.R.R.,” which we’ve determined was a WPA-era camp at which her brother Joe was spending the summer. Joe’s name was also written on this picture.

A Big Sister’s Take on a Boy’s Grandma

The part of me that deeply misses my grandma Erma since she passed away in 2000, and yearns to be able to visit her again, really felt fulfilled by seeing Aunt Nellie again.

I remember the time I’d seen her before, after the funeral of my grandma’s second husband, Max, hugging Nellie felt a lot like hugging grandma. And yeah, I miss that.

This time around, I was full of questions. Things I wished I had asked Grandma, growing up. Or had paid more attention to her answers.

Nellie confirmed the many addresses in New Phila her family called home over a period of 25 years. These moves were logged in war records, censuses, and the certificates recording three of her brothers’ untimely deaths.

I also wanted to hear about how my grandmother and grandfather met, if she could fill me in. I’d read in the article detailing their marriage announcement that grandma was a secretary in the offices of the steel mill, where my great-grandfather Foutz and two of his sons worked from way back. But my grandpa only joined the mill later on, after he’d spent years as a sales agent for the local Ford dealership.

So, how, I wondered, did a girl from New Phila end up mixing with a boy from crosstown Dover, and one some seven years her senior at that?

“Oh, your grandma got around pretty good in those days,” Nellie quipped.

“Oh, your grandma was beautiful,” one of her visitors gushed. “And a very nice lady.”

How can an enterprising reporter hold up, in the face of comments both sly and complimentary?

Another view of the old Palmer homestead in Scio, Ohio as it appeared in March 2011.

Tracing the Tree Back — Johnson & Palmer Roots

Nellie was keenly interested in some of the stops on my genealogy tour, asking about the state of the Palmer homestead, where her mother grew up and generations of the family farmed before that.

She was more interested, though, in how my parents were doing, and my wife and kids. “They should come and see me,” she said. And who could argue?

The visit ended much too soon. And I felt, not for the first time, that I’d already crammed way too much into three short days. And felt the weight, in leaving, of not knowing how soon my path would wind back her way again.

But in the work of honoring our ancestors, there are still volumes rich with information to mine.

Nellie had shared with her daughter, Sara (who in turn helps spread the word and get the family tree in order on Geni.com and Ancestry.com), the tale of her grandfather, Thomas Johnson, a Civil War mule skinner who died on a march through Mississippi in 1864. And there is limited info to go on past that, but a definite location to dig into — Guernsey County, where the Johnsons seemed to have first set up shop in Ohio.

Other connections of the family to the great conflict between the states include that of Anna (Burkey) Johnson’s father, Joseph Burkey, a soldier in Company B of the 126th regiment of the Ohio Volunteer Infantry. Military records indicate he served from May 1864 through June 1865. I’ve visited his grave and snapped a picture there, but I’d love to hunt down a photo, and more info on his time in the war.

Meanwhile, Sara has traced the Palmer connection back through Harrison County farmfields and beyond, to the Balmers of 16th century Germany. A good, yawning gap of time to gape at, and wonder at all the ancestors — and their stories — in between.

Colt’s Grandma Erma and her older sister Nellie at his high school graduation, in 1994.

A pic of the oldest Johnson kids — Leonard, Nellie and Virginia — about 1916.

Sherman Foutz: Contrasting Obits Still Yield Clues

Second Great-Uncle Sherman S. Foutz

More than One Way to Relate Life and Death

When my wife and I encounter the inevitable errors in daily newspapers — or, beginning our career as reporters, lapse into them ourselves — we often trot out my teasing twist on a saying (from somewhere): “History went and got itself up in a great… big… damn… hur… ray.”

To put it more coarsely, in the course of reporting a story and turning it around on a daily news cycle: shit happens.

Bad enough when this is part of the fluid daily record, working up dispatches on city council meetings and business transactions and arrest warrants and base hits. Somehow, pathetically, worse still when publishing those items submitted by the public for posterity, for the milestone sections of births, graduations, weddings, funerals.

In my first gig as entertainment and features writer for the Sandusky Register, I also manned the Saturday obit desk. And it was impressed upon me — right away — to follow a template, type it up slowly and triple-check my work.

Oh, and when gathering the info yourself, never to trust a single-only, no matter how well-meant, source. “If your mother says she loves you, CHECK IT OUT.” In other words, verify all info.

Well, leave it to life to allow shit to keep happenin’.

And we encounter these maxims time and again in genealogy, too. The yeoman volunteers who pore over countless census pages of centuries-old script, deciphering names that do not belong to their family tree, and doing so… erratically. Over-zealous neophyte researchers who, in their breathless haste, mistakenly prune a branch here, graft an alien trunk there, yielding cascading crops of ill-gotten family fruit. Or those who trot out a sweet, but still quite often dead wrong reasoning: because grandma said.

Remember? “If your mother says she loves you, CHECK IT OUT.”

Newspapers are wonderful troves of info. And certainly, they have been indispensable in helping to decipher what it is our case study on genealogy in my family: untangling the life, death and descendants of my great-grandfather Vance Cleveland Foutz’s oldest brother, Sherman Foutz.

When I first looked into Sherman’s story, starting in 2008 and documenting for the first time in 2010 in this blog, we had far more questions than answers. Slowly, painstakingly, we made the necessary connections, in the public record and in person with distant relatives, to fill in many missing pieces. By last year, and a series of posts tracing the family’s life in Pennsylvania through several newspaper articles, we’d put the wraps on many a mystery.

One useful tool: not just settling for one clipping of a newspaper article, but combing through related editions in the dozens of active newspapers in the early part of the 20th century. Just like in the maxim for checking out what your darling, single source says, relying on multiple versions of a milestone event can assemble a full, richer composite of the life and times you’re researching. Once, of course, you weed out the red herrings.

On Sherman Foutz’s life, I started with the yellowed clipping reporting his death that my great-grandfather had kept for nearly 55 years before his own passing. Due to the hands which cut into the newspaper, there was no month, day or year, no attributed publication. That data was to be gained from other sources — the gravestone, the death record from Denver, Colo. Curiously, though, one mystery was brought about by a simple omission — this first obituary, which I later identified as from the Harrisburg Telegraph, listed his wife, Elizabeth, and daughter, Grace, but no mention of his son, Oscar; daughter-in-law, Florence; or local grandsons.

A few years and a paid subscription to newspapers.com later, I dug up a death announcement, published the day after Sherman’s death, also in the Telegraph, which yields additional clues: age at death, address in Harrisburg, a sketch of his career with the Knights of the Maccabees and recent job change, and — voila! — mention of Oscar and his son’s address… in Arizona!

The other day, not looking for any info on Sherman, but still trying to trace more on Oscar, who doesn’t pop up again for us until his mother’s death in 1945, I found a curious third obituary. This one published in the Harrisburg Daily Independent, also on the day after Sherman died. From that Tuesday, April 6, 1915 edition:

William (sic) S. Foutz Prominent Maccabee Succumbs From Long Illness

Word was received here of the death of William (sic) S. Foutz, 135 North Summit street, who died near Denver, Col., yesterday where he had been ill for some time. He was 47 years of age. For seventeen years he was deputy and organizer of the Maccabees of the World.

For the past year Mr. Foutz was unable to attend to any business and on January 1 he left for Colorado. He is survived by his wife and daughter, Grace, of this city, and a son, Oscar, of Arizona. No arrangements for the funeral have been made, but interment will be made at Bowerstown (sic), Ohio.

So, some significant errors in the printed record here, most notably Sherman’s renaming and the misspelling of his hometown of Bowerston. But had I stumbled upon this article first, perhaps through some creative searching of the archives, I would have still gotten the tid bit on Oscar’s western location, and some additional details on how his work had suffered from his illness. No update on his change in career — for all we know, he still could have been working for the Maccabees, according to this record — and thus, I view with skepticism the specific “seventeen years” summation of his duties. But between the sources, we get a richer picture, provided we’ve done a bit more gathering of wool and smoothing out the rough parts.

“If your mother says she loves you, CHECK IT OUT.”

April 1915 obituary for Sherman Foutz lists only his wife and daughter as survivors. From the Harrisburg Telegraph.

Son Oscar Foutz is listed as a survivor — and living in Arizona — in Sherman Foutz’s 1915 death announcement.